Nightingale Pie Co.

I stopped in to get some dessert to bring to a friends place today. I purchased a fresh apple, and a frozen key lime pie. Both were delicious! If I hadn't taken the key lime pie out of the freezer myself, I would have thought it was fresh once it thawed. Thank you for your amazing desserts...I will be back :)
May 10th, 2023

Well pie you say!!! I think this deserves a better word then just pie.. masterPIEce would be a better word. I've have had pie thousands of times. This was by far the best pie I've ever had. The crust... WOW . Better then my grandmother's... flakey... light... melt in your mouth. This is truly the bar for pie. We had the honey lemon meringue pie. The sad part is I will now become diabetic as I will be trying every single pie this place sells....
May 4th, 2023

The key lime pie is so good! Can't wait to go back to try the other flavours.
Apr 2nd, 2023

Mar 26th, 2023

Mary is who you want to see if you want a tasty dessert pie. I love her mini pies that are packed with goodness! You can really tell all her fillings are fresh and home made! Nothing from a can here!!! She has expanded her menu to cookies and they are great too! My favourites are her strawberry shortcake, key lime pie and banana and pumpkin and chocolate pudding and cherry.... ugh I love them all! Tbh- I used to benefit from gifty pies when she was still a little bit my secret- but I'm so glad so many others have fallen for her pies and her sweetness! You can walk in and order online- i recommend going in early! Or you might miss out on the flavour you want- but any replacement flavour is tasty! Mary is as nice as her pies, if not sweeter! Love local and check her out!!!
Apr 19th, 2023